Like any loving pet parent you want nothing but the best for your furry friend. Sometimes, though, it’s hard to know what exactly that is. Providing the right dental care is confusing with so many options at your disposal.
Dental chews are a convenient, stress-free way to support better oral hygeine in your pet. They’re a great preventative measure that your dog loves. There are two brands we see pitted against each other all the time: Blue Buffalo Dental Chews vs Greenies. Which is better?
We’ll help you choose the right formulation for your pet below by comparing ingredients, results, suitability for different dogs, safety, and value for your money. If you just want the short answer, though, your search for the best dental chews for dogs ends here at Mighty Munch.
Our dog dental chews are professionally formulated to maximise oral health and freshen breath simultaneously, without any nasty fillers you’ll find in other products. They’re 100% safe for all breeds and ages, and exceed Australia’s pet health standards.Â
Get vet-recommended dental care today and provide your pup with the world-class support they deserve!
The Basics of Blue Buffalo Dental Chews
If you’re not familiar with Blue Buffalo dental chews already, these are just what they sound like - treats with a purpose. They’re designed to promote healthier teeth and gums in dogs through a thoughtfully shaped chewy treat that forces dogs to chew thoroughly and work through it.
Each chew features ridges and a firm texture to help reduce plaque and tartar buildup. But aside from the mechanical action of chewing, these dental chews are packed with high-quality ingredients.Â
They’re made with real chicken as the primary protein source, supported by a blend of whole grains like barley and brown rice for digestibility and energy. Added sunflower oil delivers omega fatty acids for a shinier coat, while dicalcium phosphate supports strong teeth and bones.
You’ll also find beneficial ingredients like niacin and collagen, with the latter included at a minimum of 8% to support oral tissue and joint health. What you won’t find is any poultry by-product meals, corn, wheat, soy, artificial flavours, or preservatives.
They're available in different sizes (small, medium, and large) so dogs of all breeds can benefit from the same oral care advantages. Sounds great! But, how do they stack up ot the other half of the Blue Buffalo Dental Chews vs Greenies comparison?
Overview of Greenies Dental Chews
Greenies are a long-time favourite in the pet health space, and it’s not hard to see why. They’re recommended by vets and accepted by the Veterinary Oral Health Council (VOHC).
Their distinctively chewy texture fights plaque and tartar while also freshening breath - win-win! Like Blue Buffalo, you can choose from a variety of sizes to match your pet’s weight and chewing habits. But ingredients matter most. So, what are dog dental chews made of?
The formula includes highly soluble ingredients like wheat flour, gelatin, powdered cellulose, and poultry flavour for taste and texture. There are also added vitamins and minerals support overall wellness. This falls a bit short in comparison to the Blue Buffalo formulation.
Still, Greenies are popular worldwide for a reason. They’re palatable and effective. Dogs love the flavour, pet parents appreciate how much better their dog’s breath smells - and they’re happy to offset the need for brushing, flossing, and professional cleanings as much as possible!Â
Just like in our comparison of Greenies vs Kirkland dental chews, though, we want to put the two products side-by-side to help you feel more confident and clear about which is right for you between Greenies vs Blue Buffalo dental chews.
Blue Buffalo Dental Chews vs Greenies: Which is Right for Your Pet?
Both Blue Buffalo and Greenies dental chews are a great way to improve your pet’s oral hygeine without them even knowing it. But you’ll see quite a few differences in looking at the formulations and price ranges of Blue Buffalo dental chews vs Greenies. Let’s take a look.Â
Ingredients and Nutritional Quality
This is what matters most, and we think Blue Buffalo has an edge over Greenies in ingredients and overall nutritional quality for one simple reason: they rely on whole-food-based ingredients, avoiding corn, wheat, soy, artificial preservatives, and by-product meals.
Your dog gets real chicken, brown rice, and barley to support digestibility and overall wellness. The 8% collagen for added joint and dental support is a great touch, as you may not need an additional supplement containing collagen for dogs!
Greenies, on the other hand, may cut corners in some areas. They include poultry flavour, and we have to assume that’s not coming from REAL poultry. They also contain wheat and gluten, which are potential allergens for some dogs.
However, Greenies does contain a bit more protein at 28% vs Blue Buffalo’s 23%. Greenies chews are also lower in fat, which is important for pet parents trying to keep their furry friend from gaining too much weight.
Dental Cleaning Effectiveness
Now, how do dog dental chews work? It’s all about the mechanical action of chewing. So which cleans teeth better between Greenies vs Blue Buffalo dental chews? You could really make the case for either brand/product.
Greenies have a chewy texture specifically designed to combat plaque and tartar buildup. They’ve been around a whole lot longer and have VOHC approval, so they’re an obvious choice.
That said, Blue Buffalo chews have that ridged, dense texture that works into the nooks and crannies in your dog’s mouth for a more thorough scraping effect. Still, we think Greenies may do a better job actually cleaning teeth. That’s the whole point, right?Â
Suitability by Dog Size and Age
One thing we want to give credit to both brands for is their variety of sizes, making it easy to tailor the treat to your pup’s age and weight. You’d be surprised to learn this is not the standard in the dog supplements industry!
Greenies offers a broader range of size options, from TEENIE to Large, catering to dogs from 5 to 100 lbs. You won’t have any trouble choosing the right solution.Â
Blue Buffalo offers small, medium, and large chews as well which covers most dogs, albeit with slightly less precision. Both brands recommend their products for adult dogs, though, so this is a bit of a toss-up.
Safety and Digestibility
You might be wondering…are dental sticks bad for dogs? Not if you choose between Greenies vs Blue Buffalo dental chews! Both brands are generally considered safe, assuming you’re choosing the right formulation for your pet and using the product as directed.
Still, there are discrepancies between Blue Buffalo dental chews vs Greenies dental chews that you need to be aware of. Blue Buffalo’s grain-free, naturally sourced formulation is a strong choice for dogs with sensitive stomachs or allergies. No need to worry about artificial additives!
Greenies are made with highly soluble ingredients and are widely regarded as easy to digest, but wheat could pose a problem for some dogs. Do your due diligence into any supplement you plan on adding to your pup’s regimen and ask your vet if you have any doubts.
Value for Money
Be clear, both Greenies and Blue Buffalo are cheap relative to the dog teeth cleaning cost. This is a great investment in preventative oral care for your pet. But which is the better value for the money between Blue Buffalo dental chews vs Greenies?Â
Blue Buffalo is generally priced higher per chew but includes collagen and avoids fillers. This is definitely a more premium product. Greenies offers solid value in terms of raw cleaning power and you get more chews per pack, but Blue Buffalo is the most cost-effective choice.
Of course, it all depends on where you buy them, but we see Blue Buffalo priced at $1.27 each when you buy a 28-pack. Greenies are $1.66 when you buy a 24-count. That’s the pricing for their large breed treats.
Remember, though, this is our pet’s oral health we’re talking about. You shouldn’t choose between Greenies vs Blue Buffalo dental chews based on price alone. Instead, focus on finding the best solution for your pet’s dental hygiene.Â
You actually need to branch out from either of these brands for that. Head over to Mighty Munch for dental chews that deliver the best experience at a better price.Â
Why Mighty Munch is Better Than Blue Buffalo AND Greenies
What sets Mighty Munch Dental Sticks apart from both Blue Buffalo and Greenies is a thoughtful combination of science-backed ingredients, superior manufacturing standards, and a functional formulation designed for long-term results - not just a quick chew.
While many treats rely solely on abrasive textures, we’ve taken a different approach by infusing dog probiotic strains into ours. These active bacteria help balance your dog’s oral microbiome, targeting bad breath and plaque from the inside out.
It’s a one-two punch for your pup’s oral health because like Greenies and Blue Buffalo, Mighty Munch still leverages physical cleaning while providing internal support for healthier gums and teeth.
We also stand behind the quality of our ingredients and the formulations themselves. Our products are carefully crafted in a human-grade, licensed Australian facility. They’re free from fillers, artificial colours, or preservatives.
Our dental sticks are backed by a 90-day money-back guarantee, plus they’re veterinarian-recommended and suitable for dogs of all breeds and ages.Â
You can shop with confidence today, knowing that while other brands prioritise flavour or texture, our goal is results you can see and smell. If your dog could talk, they’d beg you for Mighty Munch dental chews!
Bringing Our Comparison of Greenies vs Blue Buffalo Dental Chews to a Close
Hopefully, this comparison of Blue Buffalo dental chews vs Greenies has left you with clarity on which option is best for your pet. Each brand and product offers something unique, from the whole-food formulation of Blue Buffalo to the better plaque and tarter removal of Greenies.
Want something that fills in the gaps each has and offers the best of both worlds? Look no further than Mighty Munch. Ours actively works from the inside out. So, support your pet’s smile with the only probiotic-infused dental chew made in a human-grade Aussie facility!
