Neglecting your dog’s dental health doesn’t just lead to that notorious doggy breath. It could cause more costly problems down the road, like dog dental disease.
Let’s be honest, though, who has time to brush or floss their pet’s teeth daily? Even if you do, is this something your dog will let you do? This is the appeal of dog dental chews. Your pup will love them, and they scrape away plaque and tartar while freshening breath.
There are plenty of great brands to choose from if you want to add these to your dog’s oral care routine, including Wag dental chews vs Greenies. So which is the better option?
Wag is Amazon’s pet products brand, so you can safely assume what you’re getting there - the basics. The world’s biggest company is probably not putting your pet’s health and wellbeing before its profits.
On the other hand, Greenies is one of the original brands offering dog dental sticks. They make a great product that works well. Are these the best dental chews for dogs, though?
Mighty Munch creates dental chews dogs love and that vets recommend. They’re the #1 choice thanks to our unique probiotic formulation that improves oral hygiene from the inside out, all while scraping away plaque and tartar.
Don’t settle for less than the best for your pet - choose Mighty Munch dog supplements!
What are Wag Dental Chews?
Wag Dental Chews are part of Amazon’s private-label pet range. So how do dog dental chews work? Just like any other formula, they’re designed to help support your dog’s oral hygiene between brushings.
They reduce tartar build-up, freshen breath, and gently clean teeth as your dog chews. Even though your pet thinks they’re just enjoying another treat with a delicious meaty aroma and flavor, they’re actually getting a low cost dog teeth cleaning!
This is because of the texture of Wag dental chews, which is soft and chewy. The ridges along the treat work to scrape away plaque and food debris from the teeth and gums.
Wags are free from common fillers and allergens like added grains, corn, wheat, poultry by-products, artificial colours, or flavours. Instead, they’re made with ingredients like potato flour, chicken, parsley, green tea extract, and mint for a natural breath-freshening effect.
You’ll be able to choose between four different sizes based on your pet’s age and breed, with something for every dog from 5 to 100 pounds: Tiny, Small, Medium, and Large.
Although you may not love Amazon as a company, you might appreciate how affordable these treats are compared to other brands offering a similar product. They’re a cheap, no-fuss option for pet parents trying to care for their pet’s oral health.
What are Greenies Dental Chews?
Greenies are probably the most well-known dental treat for dogs on the market. They’re backed by the Veterinary Oral Health Council (VOHC) so you can rest assured you’re providing your pet with the level of care they need to live a long, healthy life from a dental hygiene perspective.
These treats can control plaque and tartar when used regularly. Similar to Wag’s dental chews, it comes down to the unique texture Greenies has created. They’re firm enough to scrub teeth effectively but soft enough to be safe and gentle, even for enthusiastic chewers.
The treat works to clean the gumline and reduce bad breath as dogs gnaw through them, all while keeping them occupied - everyone wins! The formulation consists of mostly natural ingredients, fortified with vitamins and minerals to support overall health.
But what are dog dental chews made of, exactly? The biggest issue we see with Greenies is the inclusion of wheat flour and wheat gluten, meaning they may not be right for dogs with grain sensitivities or allergies.
That being said, Greenies offers a full range of options tailored to size, age, and even specific needs like weight management, from puppies to seniors. They’re certainly worth exploring further if you want to protect your pet’s oral health.
Because Greenies is among the most popular brands for dog dental chews we’ve put together a comparison of Greenies vs Kirkland dental chews to help pet parents choose the right formula.
But what about Wag dental chews vs Greenies? Let’s take a closer look at these two brands side by side below to see which has an edge.
Wag Dental Chews vs Greenies: Which is the Better Choice for Your Dog?
We want to preface this by saying both Wag and Greenies dental sticks can be a great way to support oral health in dogs - they’re accessible, simple, and work well to reduce plaque and bad breath with daily use.
If we had to give you a quick recommendation between Wag dental chews vs Greenies, it would definitely be the latter for its clinical backing and vet recommendations - and because they’re not Amazon, it’s really that simple!
But like we said from the start, we’ve developed a more advanced chew that goes beyond surface-level cleaning here at Mighty Munch. Our formulation features probiotics to target bad breath and dental health from the inside out, supporting gut and gum health simultaneously.
Nevertheless, we’ll walk you through the distinct differences between Wag vs Greenies below.
Ingredients and Nutrition
Pet parents ask us all the time, are dental sticks bad for dogs? Not at all - at least, not when you choose a formulation with high-quality ingredients tailored to your pet’s health!
Wag Dental Chews use a relatively short ingredient list with potato flour, chicken, parsley, and mint. No need to stress about grains, corn, or artificial additives. Even the most sensitive stomachs can enjoy Wag chews without worry!
On the other hand, Greenies’ ingredient lineup is a bit more broad - with wheat flour, wheat gluten, gelatin, vitamins, and minerals. The treats are enriched with nutrients like vitamin E, B-complex vitamins, and calcium to support overall health.
The problem is, they’re not grain-free. So they might not work for every dog. Wag looks to be the safer bet in this sense, BUT, Greenies does have the better formulation from a nutritional content perspective as long as your dog is not sensitive to grains. Choose accordingly.
Reducing Plaque, Tartar, and Bad Breath
The whole point of dental chews is to improve oral health - reducing plaque, tartar, and bad breath between professional cleanings or at-home brushings. So which solution works better?
Greenies has a strong track record here, especially with the VOHC seal of approval. The texture has been clinically tested to reduce plaque and tartar when used daily.
In contrast, Wag chews haven’t gone through the same level of formal testing as Greenies. So all we can do is look at real customer reviews to get a sense of how well they work, and we see a fairly mixed bag of results there.
Some customers say the chews are far too soft to really remove plaque/tartar effectively. Others claim the treats are rock hard and break apart too easily. It appears there are some consistency concerns.
This isn’t all that surprising considering it’s an Amazon brand focused on providing the cheapest solution at scale rather than providing the absolute best product. While both Wag vs Greenies dental chews work, the latter takes the cake here.
Digestibility and Stomach Sensitivity Considerations
Wag chews are grain-free and don’t include common allergens like wheat, corn, or soy. As we touched on a bit already, they’re probably the safer choice if your dog has known food intolerances or simply a sensitive stomach.
Greenies is still highly digestible for most dogs, but remember, they do contain wheat and gluten. This could pose a problem for dogs with food allergies, even though the dental chews are made with highly soluble ingredients that break down easily in the digestive system.
Flavor Options and Dog Preferences
If only you could let your dog try both and have them tell you which they preferred…life would be so much easier if pets could talk!
Although that’s not possible, Greenies does cater to all palates with multiple flavours and formulas - original, blueberry, weight management, and more. Pawrents can match the choice to their dog’s taste and health needs.
You’ll have fewer options at your disposal with Wag dental chews. They look to be available in just a single savoury variety - but most dogs do love the taste and aroma. Pet parents, not so much. That’s another common theme we see in the reviews: they see the aroma is unpleasant!
Cost and Value for Money
We want to be clear in saying you shouldn’t choose between Wag dental chews vs Greenies based on taste alone. You get what you pay for. That said, Wag is definitely the cheaper option here. That’s what you’d expect from an Amazon brand, after all!
You get 24 treats for just under $29 with Wag. In contrast, Greenies cost just under $40 for the same quantity. But what matters more than cost is value. We think Greenies has the edge here.
Because remember, you’re getting added nutrients, VOHC assurance, and more flavour options. Plus, the chews just work better - so if you’re trying to care for your pet’s oral hygiene, why would you settle for what’s cheaper instead of choosing what’s better?
Brand Transparency and Manufacturing Practices
Greenies is part of the Mars Petcare family, a company known for maintaining high manufacturing standards. We hate to sound like a broken record, but that’s why they’re VOHC-approved. Greenies also shares the exact nutritional content for their products clearly.
On the other hand, Wag offers less transparency as an Amazon private-label brand. Ingredient sourcing and manufacturing details aren’t always clear. We mentioned texture inconsistencies earlier, and this is another example of not really knowing how the treats are made or tested.
Why Mighty Munch Dental Chews are Preferred to Both Wag and Greenies
There you have it, a thorough Wag dental chews vs Greenies dental chews comparison. While you could make the case of either brand in some way or another, we said from the start that you’re technically settling for less than the best if you choose Greenies OR Wag.
Here at Mighty Munch we’ve developed the #1 vet-recommended dental sticks that work from the inside out. What sets them apart is the dog probiotics we’ve included in the formulation, which promotes healthy bacteria balance in the mouth and digestive system.
This is how these treats are able to actively improve breath for the long haul rather than just cover it up after a dog chews through the treat. But, they also scrape away plaque and tartar to clean your dog’s teeth well.
We take our quality seriously and produce all our supplements in a human-grade facility right here in Australia, sourcing nothing but the BEST ingredients for our dental sticks. We don’t settle for less than the best in our own pets’ wellness, and you shouldn’t, either.
Mighty Munch is trusted by thousands of Australian pet parents, and it’s safe for all breeds and life stages. Giving your dog a dental treat daily is a simple habit that delivers real, noticeable results - for breath, teeth, and overall wellbeing. Get started today!
Final Words on Wag vs Greenies
While giving your pet dental chews is a step in the right direction for improving their oral hygiene, the specific product you add to their wellness regimen matters. We hope this comparison of Wag dental chews vs Greenies has left you clear about which is best.
Wag is affordable and grain-free, while Greenies offers vet-backed performance with added nutrients. But maybe you want more than just surface-level cleaning. That’s why Mighty Munch is the #1 formulation on the market right now.
You get not just plaque and tartar removal but probiotic infusion to support dental and digestive health in one smart chew. Our products are vet-recommended and backed by countless success stories - so give your dog the chew that works from the inside out today!
